Six thinking hats: one subject, six ways of looking at it, everyone at the same time

Written by the IdeaHone Editorial Team · · 5 min read

A pile of colourful felt hats

Run this method in IdeaHone

Creates a space with the entities and scoring criteria of this method, ready for your next session.

Run in IdeaHone

Most discussions about a new plan go in circles for the same reason. One person lists risks while another defends the benefits, a third brings a new idea, and a fourth asks what the numbers say. Everyone is right, but nobody is thinking about the same thing at the same time, so every point gets an immediate counterpoint. Edward de Bono described a way out in his book Six Thinking Hats (1985). The group puts on the same "hat" together, one way of thinking at a time, and works through all six. He called it parallel thinking: side by side instead of against each other.

The six hats

HatWay of thinkingTypical question
WhiteFacts and informationWhat do we know, and what is missing?
RedFeelings and intuitionWhat is your gut reaction, without reasons?
YellowBenefits and valueWhy could this work, and for whom?
BlackCaution and risksWhy could this fail? What are the weak points?
GreenIdeas and alternativesWhat else could we try? How could we fix the risks?
BlueThe processWhat have we learned, what do we decide, what happens next?

The black hat is not the negative one. It is the careful critic, and it is often the most useful hat of all, as long as it has its own slot instead of interrupting every other one.

Running the six hats in 45 minutes

  1. Name the subject in one line. One plan, decision or idea: "Refill stations in all 12 stores next year". A vague subject gives vague hats.
  2. Agree on the order. A good default for judging a plan: white, red, yellow, black, green, blue. The blue hat frames the session at the start and pulls it together at the end.
  3. Wear one hat at a time, everyone together. Five minutes per hat, written alone first, then read out. No one comments on a point with another hat.
  4. Keep the red hat short. Thirty seconds to two minutes. Gut reactions do not need justification, and asking for reasons turns them into arguments.
  5. Give the black hat its full time. Collect every risk, then move on. The green hat that follows looks for ways around the biggest ones.
  6. Close with the blue hat. What did we learn, what do we decide, who does what by when? Without this step the session ends as a long list.

Writing before talking matters as much as the hats. When everyone writes first, the quiet specialist's risk counts as much as the loudest opinion. In IdeaHone, everyone writes on their phone under the same hat, and each hat's notes land in the space as their own type: facts, feelings and benefits as insights, black hat points as risks, green hat points as ideas, blue hat points as next steps.

When to use the six hats

  • Before a decision on a plan or concept. It makes sure the risks and the benefits both get a full hearing.
  • When a meeting keeps going in circles. Switching to one hat at a time stops the back and forth.
  • With mixed seniority. A defined slot for the black hat makes criticism expected instead of risky.

For finding risks alone, a pre-mortem goes deeper. For new ideas alone, reverse brainstorming or brainwriting usually produce more. The six hats are strongest when a subject needs all six views in one session.

Where six-hats sessions go wrong

  • Hats as personalities. "Anna is our black hat" defeats the point. Everyone wears every hat.
  • Skipping hats. Teams skip red because feelings seem unprofessional, or black because the plan is the boss's. The skipped hat comes back later, as resistance.
  • Debating inside a hat. Under the yellow hat nobody says "but". Write the "but" down for the black hat.
  • No decision at the end. Six lists are not a result. The blue hat turns them into a decision and next steps, or into a decision workshop.

Six Thinking Hats is a registered trademark of Edward de Bono Limited. The method was described by Edward de Bono in Six Thinking Hats (1985). This article explains the method for educational purposes; IdeaHone is not affiliated with or endorsed by the de Bono organisation, and its activity type is called "Six hats".

Run the workshop. IdeaHone keeps the record.

While you facilitate, IdeaHone turns what is said into ideas, questions and decisions on a shared board, with who said it. Nobody writes the minutes afterwards.

Request a demo

What are the six thinking hats?

A method by Edward de Bono for group thinking. Six coloured hats stand for six ways of thinking: white for facts, red for feelings, yellow for benefits, black for risks, green for ideas and blue for the process. The group wears one hat at a time, all together.

What is parallel thinking?

Everyone in a group thinks in the same direction at the same time, for example all looking for risks, instead of arguing one view against another. It is the idea behind the six thinking hats.

In which order do you use the six hats?

There is no single correct order. A common one for judging a plan is white, red, yellow, black, green, blue, with blue also used at the start to set the goal. For finding new ideas, start with white and green.

How long should each hat take?

About five minutes for most hats, and only one or two minutes for the red hat. A full session takes 30 to 60 minutes.

All resources