The energy curve of an ideation workshop: when to push and when to stop

The brilliant idea round is scheduled for 15:30, right after lunch and the status update, in a room where half the people are checking mail. Nobody says it, but that round was lost when the agenda was written. Energy in a workshop follows a predictable curve, and a facilitator who knows it plans against it instead of fighting it. This guide shows where the highs and dips fall in a workshop day and what belongs in each phase.
Why the curve matters
Most agendas are built around content: briefing, then ideas, then decisions. The room does not care about content. It cares whether it is 9:20 or 14:10, whether there has been a break, and whether the last 40 minutes were spent listening or talking. You cannot change the curve. You can change what you put on top of it, which is how the 90-minute ideation workshop agenda is built.
The curve of a workshop day
The first 15 minutes
The room is polite and cautious. Nobody will say anything risky yet, so do not ask for it. Use this phase for framing: the question of the day on the wall, the rules, the timing. Then run one round where everyone speaks once, for thirty seconds, on something easy. The second contribution costs much less.
The first high (minutes 20 to 60)
The best time of the whole day for generation. People are fresh, warmed up and not yet tired of each other. Protect it: no slides, no status update, no "quick input from the sponsor". Put your main generation round here, silent first (a brainwriting 6-3-5 round works well), then out loud.
The dip (minutes 60 to 75)
Around the one-hour mark the room goes quiet. People have given their obvious ideas and are waiting for someone else to go first. This moment decides the workshop. The facilitator either pushes through with a second, sharper question, or calls a real break. Both can be right. Asking "anything else?" three times is never right.
The second high
After a real break (ten minutes, out of the room) the energy comes back, but different. People produce fewer new ideas and react more to what is on the wall. Use this for building and merging: pair similar ideas, ask what would make one bigger, let people steal from each other.
The long afternoon
From roughly 13:30 onwards, judgement works and generation does not. People can read, compare and score; they cannot invent. Schedule scoring, clustering and decisions here; a decision workshop block fits this slot exactly. A fresh idea round at 15:00 is one of the most common scheduling mistakes.
The last 20 minutes
Energy comes back when the end is in sight. People sit up and want to leave with something. Use it for owners and dates: who takes which idea, what happens by when. Not for one more idea. An idea born in the last ten minutes has no owner and will be the first to disappear.
The curve at a glance
| Time | Typical energy | Best use | Worst use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minutes 0 to 15 | Polite, cautious | Framing, one easy round for everyone | Asking for bold ideas |
| Minutes 20 to 60 | First high | Main generation round | Slides, status updates |
| Minutes 60 to 75 | Dip | Second question or a real break | "Anything else?" |
| After the break | Second high | Building on and merging ideas | Starting from zero |
| Afternoon | Low but steady | Scoring, clustering, decisions | Fresh generation |
| Last 20 minutes | Rising | Owners, dates, next step | One more idea round |
Rules for pushing
- Push only when the dip is about ideas, not about people. "We have said the obvious" is a reason to push. "We are tired" is a reason to break. Bored people lean back; tired people look at their phones.
- Change the question, not the volume. Louder encouragement produces nothing. A new angle does: what would a competitor do, what would we do with half the budget.
- A push lasts ten minutes, not thirty. Announce the time, run it, stop. If nothing comes, the room needs a break, not a third question.
Rules for stopping
- Stop a round when two people in a row repeat what is already on the wall. The pool is empty for now. Say it plainly: "That is the end of this round, and it is a good sign."
- Stop the day when decisions are made, not when the agenda is finished. If owners and dates are agreed at 15:40 and the agenda says 16:30, let people go.
Schedule the hardest thinking before the first break and the hardest decisions after the last one. Everything else can go in the middle.
Energisers do not fix a bad agenda. If the room is flat at 10:30, the question on the wall is wrong, not the people. Rewrite the question before you make anyone stand up and clap.
Choices that sink the room's energy
- Slides after lunch. Twenty minutes of slides at 13:30 puts the room to sleep for an hour. Present before the break or send it in advance.
- Generation after judgement. Once the room has scored ideas, it keeps scoring. Every new idea is judged in the first second.
- A break "when we are done with this". Breaks run on the clock. A room that is promised a break in ten minutes stops working now.
- The facilitator mistakes their own energy for the room's. You have been standing and talking for two hours and feel great. The room has been sitting. Watch them, not yourself; a live record of the session (tools like IdeaHone keep one) lets you watch the room instead of the wall.
Run the workshop. IdeaHone keeps the record.
While you facilitate, IdeaHone turns what is said into ideas, questions and decisions on a shared board, with who said it. Nobody writes the minutes afterwards.
When is the best time in a workshop for brainstorming?
Between minute 20 and minute 60, after a short warm-up round and before the first break. Avoid any generation round in the first hour after lunch.
How long should a workshop block be?
A generation block runs 30 to 40 minutes, a scoring or decision block 20 to 45 minutes, and no block should run longer than 60 minutes without a real break.
What do you do when workshop energy drops?
Decide whether the room is out of ideas or out of energy. Out of ideas: change the question and give it ten minutes. Out of energy: take a real ten-minute break, out of the room.